Implementation and Trial Preparation Considerations: A Case Review of the First Successful NGS Admissibility Hearing in the US

Implementation and Trial Preparation Considerations: A Case Review of the First Successful NGS Admissibility Hearing in the US

In 2022, one laboratory’s journey from traditional forensic DNA testing methods to next generation sequencing (NGS) was explored. In 2023, that journey concluded with the first successful admissibility hearing of NGS data in the United States. Identity SNP, aSTR and Y-STR DNA profiles obtained from the evidence collected from the crime scene samples of the double homicide were presented at the hearing and expert testimony was heard exploring the evolution of DNA testing, laying the scientific foundation for NGS technology, and addressing the applications of sequencing data for identification.

Laboratories considering implementing new technology, whether it be NGS or another advanced technology, are faced with a multitude of decisions, often making the task seem overwhelming. This presentation aims to address key components of the transition strategy including implementation considerations, case and sample selection for testing, expert witness selection criteria, and comprehensive trial preparation encompassing discovery materials and evidentiary presentation. A detailed case review will look further into how NGS was utilized in trial for the conviction of subject Adrian Chavez.

In 2022, one laboratory’s journey from traditional forensic DNA testing methods to next generation sequencing (NGS) was explored. In 2023, that journey concluded with the first successful admissibility hearing of NGS data in the United States. Identity SNP, aSTR and Y-STR DNA profiles obtained from the evidence collected from the crime scene samples of the double homicide were presented at the hearing and expert testimony was heard exploring the evolution of DNA testing, laying the scientific foundation for NGS technology, and addressing the applications of sequencing data for identification.

Laboratories considering implementing new technology, whether it be NGS or another advanced technology, are faced with a multitude of decisions, often making the task seem overwhelming. This presentation aims to address key components of the transition strategy including implementation considerations, case and sample selection for testing, expert witness selection criteria, and comprehensive trial preparation encompassing discovery materials and evidentiary presentation. A detailed case review will look further into how NGS was utilized in trial for the conviction of subject Adrian Chavez.

Workshop currently at capacity. A waitlist is available to join on our registration page.

Brought to you by

Worldwide Association of Women Forensic Experts

Mandi Van Buren

DNA Analyst, DNA Labs International (DLI)

Mandi Van Buren began her forensic career at the Utah Bureau of Forensic Services and now has over 15 years of experience as a DNA analyst in forensic casework, crime scene processing and 7 years as a drug chemist.  Beyond casework, her expertise is in advanced DNA technologies such as next generation sequencing (NGS) and probabilistic genotyping including validations, implementation, training and expert testimony. 

Speaker Image

Submit Question to a speaker